Skip to main content
CSV/CSAMaturity

Free self-assessment

CSV/CSA Maturity Assessment

Understand how consistently your team manages computer system validation and computer software assurance. Review 18 questions across seven practice areas, then explore your maturity profile and priority actions.

Free self-assessment. Transparent scoring. No certification or compliance verdict.

After answering, you will be asked for contact details before seeing your profile. Read how your information and assessment are used before you start. Privacy notice

How the scoring works

The assessment

Describe your current practice

Seven areas, one at a time. Nothing is preselected, and you can go back without losing an answer.

  1. Scope and answers
  2. Review
  3. Your details
  4. Your profile

Scope0 of 18 questions addressed

Scope

Start with your scope

Choose one team, site or system portfolio to assess. Keep that scope consistent throughout.

Which scope are you assessing? (required)

This adds context, not a compliance determination. It does not change the scoring.

Keep confidential material out

Use your internal records to inform your answers. Do not upload confidential documents or enter system names here.

Before you start. After answering, you will be asked for contact details before seeing your profile. Read how your information and assessment are used before you start. Privacy notice

Powered by ValidforModel csa-maturity-2.0.0

How the scoring works

Clear this assessment

Clear this assessment? Your answers, scope and profile on this device will be removed. Details you already submitted are not deleted by clearing this page.

How it works

From a chosen scope to a practice profile

  1. Choose your scope

    Decide which team, site or system portfolio your answers describe. A narrow, consistent scope is more useful than mixing strong practices from one area with weak practices from another.

  2. Describe current practice

    Select the closest evidenced answer for each question. Use “I do not know yet” when you cannot support a choice. The assessment is not an examination and you do not gain credibility by choosing the highest option.

  3. Review your answers

    Check every answer against the same scope before you finish. A complete score is available only when every question has a scored response. A partial profile remains useful without inventing missing answers.

  4. Share your details and see your profile

    Before your profile is shown you are asked for your name, work email and company. You then see strengths, gaps and unanswered evidence questions, and can download a report.

The seven areas

What the questions cover

Each area carries equal weight in the overall result, whatever its number of questions. The evidence prompts tell you what to have at hand before you answer.

System inventory

Whether the computerized systems in your chosen scope can be identified, have accountable owners, and carry a documented decision about their relevance to regulated work.

Evidence that helps you answer
A current system inventory, named owners, a relevance rationale and a recent reconciliation record.
Questions
2 (Q01, Q02)

Build an inventory you can maintain

Intended use

Whether each system's real operational use is described clearly, and whether important needs and acceptance expectations are agreed by the people who use and oversee it.

Evidence that helps you answer
A current intended-use statement, its approving owner and a requirements sample with clear acceptance expectations.
Questions
2 (Q03, Q04)

Write a clearer intended-use statement

Risk-based assurance

Whether assurance effort follows documented function-level risk reasoning, whether the chosen activities are justified, and how unexpected results are handled before release.

Evidence that helps you answer
A function-level risk assessment, the assurance rationale it led to, and an issue record with its disposition.
Questions
3 (Q05, Q06, Q07)

Connect risk reasoning to assurance

Traceability

Whether a reviewer can connect important needs and risks to the assurance evidence, identify the exact evidence version relied on, and keep those links intact through change.

Evidence that helps you answer
One trace from a need through risk, activity and evidence, with the approved evidence version and a changed item's updated links.
Questions
3 (Q08, Q09, Q10)

Follow one evidence chain

Change management

Whether the impact of internal changes and supplier releases is assessed before reliance, and whether systems are reviewed for continued suitability over time.

Evidence that helps you answer
A recent change with its impact rationale and closure, a supplier release assessment and a completed lifecycle review.
Questions
3 (Q11, Q12, Q13)

Review a change-impact decision

Approvals and record controls

Whether review and approval responsibility is controlled, and whether the records used for assurance decisions are protected and retrievable, across paper, hybrid and electronic media.

Evidence that helps you answer
A record showing who approved it and why they were authorized, plus the access, retention and retrieval controls that apply to it.
Questions
2 (Q14, Q15)

Compare approval and record controls

Evidence and review readiness

Whether a coherent evidence package can be retrieved, whether responsibilities and competence are maintained, and whether findings are followed through to effective closure.

Evidence that helps you answer
A sample evidence package with a retrieval exercise, a responsibility matrix with competence evidence, and an action record with its closure rationale.
Questions
3 (Q16, Q17, Q18)

Turn gaps into an owned improvement plan

How scoring works

A calculation you can reproduce

Each scored answer is assigned a value from 0 to 3. Questions contribute equally within their area, and the seven areas contribute equally to the overall result. Unknown answers remain unknown: they are not treated as zero or as evidence of compliance. The methodology explains the calculation, bands and version history.

Read the full methodology

Model csa-maturity-2.0.0
Question bank 2.0.0

The formulas

Area score
100 × (sum of answer values) ÷ (3 × questions in the area)
Overall score
(sum of the seven area scores) ÷ 7
Numeric coverage
100 × (numeric answers) ÷ 18

The four bands

Maturity bands and the displayed scores they cover
BandDisplayed score
Ad hoc0.0 to below 25.0
Developing25.0 to below 50.0
Defined50.0 to below 75.0
Measured75.0 to 100.0

Band names belong to this self-report rubric. They are not regulatory categories or certifications.

Three kinds of response
A practice description is one of four statements valued 0 to 3; a selected 0 counts in the calculation as zero. “I do not know yet” counts as addressed and never as zero. An unanswered question keeps the assessment open until you choose a description or an explicit unknown.
Rounding and bands
The overall score is calculated from the unrounded area values. Scores are rounded half up to one decimal place for display, and the band is taken from the displayed value, so a displayed 25.0 is never labelled Ad hoc.
Unknown answers and the possible range
An area with an unknown answer shows a possible range instead of a score, and the profile has no overall score or band. The lower bound substitutes 0 for each unknown, the upper bound substitutes 3, and both are rounded outward. It is a mathematical interval, not a prediction or a confidence interval.
Review prompts
Questions Q02, Q05 and Q15 raise a separate review prompt when answered with the lowest description, and a verification prompt when unknown. Prompts never change the arithmetic, and a high total does not suppress them.
Why the areas are weighted equally
Equal weighting keeps every area equally visible despite different question counts. It is a design choice for a planning model, not a claim that all controls carry equal operational or regulatory risk.
What cannot move the score
Company size, email domain, buying software, using AI and interest in any vendor are not inputs. A well-controlled manual or hybrid process can meet the highest description.

Worked example

A sample profile, with the arithmetic shown

Illustrative profile. These answers were created to explain the model. They do not describe a customer, an industry average or a recommended target.

Illustrative, not a real result

Self-reported maturity score

54.8/100

Defined

Your answers describe a documented baseline across several areas. Check whether it is applied consistently and how changes are handled.

Numeric coverage
18 of 18 numeric answers (100.0%)
Review prompts
None

Load the example answers

This will replace your current answers. Load the example?

Loads these answers into the assessment so you can step through them. You are asked to confirm first, because it replaces any answers you have given.

Worked example: answer values, calculation, score and band for each of the seven areas
AreaAnswer valuesCalculationArea scoreBand
System inventory2, 2100 × 4 ÷ (3 × 2)66.7Defined
Intended use2, 1100 × 3 ÷ (3 × 2)50.0Defined
Risk-based assurance1, 2, 2100 × 5 ÷ (3 × 3)55.6Defined
Traceability2, 2, 1100 × 5 ÷ (3 × 3)55.6Defined
Change management1, 1, 2100 × 4 ÷ (3 × 3)44.4Developing
Approvals and record controls2, 2100 × 4 ÷ (3 × 2)66.7Defined
Evidence and review readiness1, 2, 1100 × 4 ÷ (3 × 3)44.4Developing
Overall score
The mean of the seven unrounded area values is 54.76190476, displayed as 54.8: Defined.
Not a pooled average
The 18 answer values sum to 29. Pooling them, 100 × 29 ÷ 54, would give 53.7. That is not this model: each area contributes equally, whatever its number of questions.
What it would suggest first
  1. Assess change impact before implementation (Change management)
  2. Run a small evidence-retrieval exercise (Evidence and review readiness)
  3. Agree needs and acceptance expectations (Intended use)

This is a suggested sequence for a discussion, not a risk classification. A qualified reviewer may reprioritize based on the actual systems, intended use and evidence.

Results explained

What the result means

The maturity profile is a structured description of the practices you report. It is not a probability of passing an inspection, a percentage of regulatory compliance or a comparison with other companies. Use it to organize a discussion with the people responsible for the work.

How to read each band

Ad hoc0.0 to below 25.0
Your answers describe practices that are not yet consistently established in the selected scope. Start with ownership, intended use and evidence you can verify.
Developing25.0 to below 50.0
Some practices are established, but consistency and review need attention. Choose specific gaps rather than trying to improve every score at once.
Defined50.0 to below 75.0
Your answers describe a documented baseline across several areas. Check whether it is applied consistently and how changes are handled.
Measured75.0 to 100.0
Your answers describe practices that are reviewed and maintained. Verify the supporting evidence and examine any weaker area separately; the label does not establish control effectiveness.

“Measured” is a name in this self-report rubric. It does not mean that the evidence has been inspected, that all controls are effective, or that an organization is compliant.

Where to begin after a low score

Start with the specific practice and evidence gap, not the number alone. Confirm the scope, identify the responsible owner and inspect a relevant sample record. Agree the next action and the evidence that would demonstrate improvement. A lower score can be a useful planning signal; it is not a finding issued by a regulator.

A high total can still carry a review point

A high score and a specific review prompt can appear together. The profile shows both, because an average can conceal a weaker practice. A prompt asks you to inspect the evidence and context. It is not a declaration of noncompliance.

A partial profile is still useful

When some answers are “I do not know yet”, the profile shows numeric coverage, the areas that could be scored and a possible range for the rest. It gives no overall score or band, and it starts with the evidence to verify.

Limitations

What this assessment does not do

This self-assessment summarizes the practices you report for a selected team, site or system portfolio. It is a planning aid, not an audit, certification or determination of compliance. Regulatory expectations depend on your activities, systems and jurisdiction. Review applicability with your responsible quality and regulatory specialists.

  • Not a compliance determination

    It is not an audit, a certification, an inspection simulation or a regulatory determination. A self-reported profile cannot establish compliance or predict an inspection outcome.

  • Not a benchmark

    No representative comparison population has been established. The score is not a percentile, a market ranking or a comparison with other organizations.

  • Not evidence verification

    The assessment does not inspect systems, read documents or check that records support your answers. It has no upload, and you should not enter system names or confidential details.

Regulatory context depends on your activities

The FDA guidance Computer Software Assurance for Production and Quality Management System Software addresses software used in medical device production and quality management systems. It does not automatically govern every pharmaceutical or laboratory application. For EU medicinal products, the Annex 11 text in force is the January 2011 revision, and the 2025 revision materials are consultation drafts. Whether Part 11 applies depends on the records and their context. This assessment does not decide which of these apply to you, and computer software assurance does not mean no testing or no records.

Further reading

Guides for a better-evidenced answer

Practical reading for before and after the assessment. Your answers stay in place while you read.

  1. How-to

    Build a GxP Computerized System Inventory You Can Maintain

    An inventory is only useful while it stays current. This how-to sets the boundary, reconciles the lists you already have, names owners and records relevance decisions, with a copyable template and three synthetic rows.

    Published 10 min read

  2. Tutorials

    Interpret a CSV/CSA Maturity Profile: A Worked Example

    Follow one synthetic profile from 18 answers to seven area scores and an overall 54.8. Then see what changes when three answers are unknown, and why a 92.9 can still carry a review prompt.

    Published 11 min read

  3. Guides

    Turn a CSV/CSA Maturity Profile into an Owned Improvement Plan

    A CSV/CSA maturity profile tells you where to look. An improvement plan says who will do what, what will show it was done and who will check. This guide walks from one to the other in nine steps, with an action register you can copy.

    Published 10 min read

FAQ

Questions about the assessment

Short, direct answers. The methodology page explains the calculation, the bands and the version history in full.

What does the CSV/CSA Maturity Assessment measure?

It measures how you describe your own practices in seven areas of computer system validation and computer software assurance, for one team, site or system portfolio. The result is a self-reported profile with evidence prompts and suggested next steps. The assessment does not inspect your systems, read your records or verify that an answer is supported by evidence, so the profile is a planning aid and not an audit finding.

What do CSV and CSA mean in this assessment?

CSV means computer system validation and CSA means computer software assurance. Here CSV does not mean a comma-separated values file. Both abbreviations are industry shorthand for validation and assurance practices applied to computerized systems in regulated work. The assessment uses them to describe practices. It does not determine which regulatory requirements apply to your organization, your systems or your records.

Who should complete the assessment, and what scope should it cover?

A person or small group who knows the selected systems and quality processes should complete it. System owners, validation or assurance staff, process owners and quality colleagues often need to compare evidence together. Choose one clear boundary, such as one team, one site or a defined system portfolio, and keep it for every answer. Where practices differ materially between sites, assess each one separately instead of averaging them.

How many questions are there, and how long does the assessment take?

There are 18 questions across seven practice areas. Each question offers four practice descriptions and an explicit "I do not know yet" option. No completion time is published, because the time depends on how well you already know the supporting practices and evidence. You can select the unknown option wherever information needs checking, so there is no reason to rush or to guess an answer.

What happens when I select "I do not know yet"?

The answer stays unknown and is never scored as zero. Your profile becomes partial: it shows numeric coverage, a score for each practice area you answered in full and a possible range for the overall result. A partial profile has no overall score and no maturity band until every question has a numeric answer. The useful next step is to verify the evidence behind each unknown answer.

Does the assessment certify compliance or audit readiness?

No. The assessment is not an audit, a certification, an inspection simulation or a regulatory determination. A self-reported profile cannot establish compliance or predict an inspection outcome, and it does not decide whether a system, record or signature falls under a requirement such as EU GMP Annex 11 or 21 CFR Part 11. Use the profile to organize a discussion and to point qualified people at the evidence that needs review.

Does FDA's computer software assurance guidance apply to every pharmaceutical system?

No. FDA's final guidance on computer software assurance, issued in February 2026, gives nonbinding recommendations for software used as part of medical device production or the quality management system. It does not address pharmaceutical manufacturing, laboratory or clinical systems, so do not assume that it governs them. Which framework applies to a given system is a question for your qualified quality and regulatory specialists, and the assessment does not answer it.

Do I need automation, AI or a particular software product to score well?

No. The questions look at how clear, consistent and reviewed your practices are, not at which technology you bought. A well-controlled manual or hybrid process can match the highest practice description, and no answer earns points for using automation, AI or any vendor's product. Buying software does not by itself raise a maturity score, and a poorly governed automated process can score lower than a controlled manual one.

Can I compare my maturity score with other companies?

No. No representative benchmark population exists for this assessment, so the score is not a percentile, an industry average or a market ranking. It describes the practices you reported for one scope under one model version. Compare a result only with an earlier result for the same scope and the same model version, and record what changed between the two before drawing a conclusion.

Do I need to give contact details to see my profile?

Yes. After the review step and before your profile is shown, a short form asks for your first name, last name, work email and company. The details go to Validfor, the company that powers the assessment, which uses them to prepare your profile and to respond to you about it. This is stated on the page before you start. You can read every question and the full scoring method without giving any details, and marketing email is a separate choice.

Can I download my profile as a PDF?

Yes. Once your profile is shown you can download it as a PDF report. The report contains your scope, your answers, the profile, the model version and suggested next actions, so you can share it with the people responsible for the work. The file is created when you ask for it and contains no contact details. It is not sent by email, and downloading it does not request a call or subscribe you to marketing.

What happens to my answers and contact details?

Scoring runs in your browser while you answer, and the profile is recomputed on the server when you submit the contact form. The contact details and assessment answers you submit are stored by this site and sent to Validfor, the company that powers the assessment, to prepare your profile and respond to you. The site's analytics is cookieless and never receives answers or scores. The privacy notice at /privacy describes each step and explains how to make a request about your data.